Yet another prop discussion.

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • perry386
    Senior Member of PLANETNAUTIQUE
    • Jun 2012
    • 560

    • gadsden AL

    • Super Air nautique 236

    Yet another prop discussion.

    Hey guys, I know there have been a lot of prop threads on here but I'm wanting some opinions. The other day I was out and I was noticing really bad prop cavitation, to the point that we had to stop wakeboarding for the day . I am currently running a 1235 on an 08 230 Zr6. The prop has been reworked many times because of my nasty river so we decided it was time to just buy a new one. I got on the internet and found a propeller buying guide chart for the 230 and it suggested the 644,1161,1579, and 1235. Since I already had the 1235 I thought I would give one of the others a try. I decided on the 1579 and was just wondering what y'all's thoughts on this prop were. When I wakeboard I only run stock ballast and when I surf I only have one 400# sac that I fill. Do you guys think this will be plenty of prop for me? I made the switch because I don't want to have to deal with cavitation again.
  • core-rider
    1,000 Post Club Member
    • Feb 2004
    • 1345

    • Huntsville, AL

    • 2003 Black SANTE

    #2
    Not sure what "prop buying guide chart" you were looking at, but it wasn't a very good one! The 644 won't work at all as it is RH rotation. You would need a 645. With that being said, really if the only issue you have was prop-slip or cavitation and your current prop is out of spec... I would stick with the 1235. The 1161 and 1579 are both 1" smaller in diameter and the 1161 has almost 2" less pitch making them far less superior to the 1235. There will be a noticable difference in hole-shot. Diameter makes a huge difference IMHO in hole-shot and top speed. You will move less water, which means the boat will move slower.

    There is a reason people running tons of ballast on 210s and 230s swap from the 1579 (stock prop) to 1235 (power prop)! If you aren't having issues with prop burn on the hull keep the 1235, else look into the 1433. Talk to ACME and they will most likely repeat what I've said. If anything I would look at a 5 blade like the 2245. Seems like the reviews on 5 blade props are 50/50 though. ACME has a program that will allow you to swap out props for testing you can talk with them about as well.
    Jason
    All black 2003 SANTE
    -- Southern Fried --

    Comment

    • nyryan2001
      1,000 Post Club Member
      • Mar 2013
      • 1993

      • Lake Anna


      #3
      Perry-

      Need you to answer this:

      Are you happy with the performance of the 1235?

      Do you want/need more torque to carry more weight?

      is there a top speed you need to maintain else it'll be a show stopper?
      2019 G23 450
      2014 G23 550
      2013 G23 450
      2011 Malibu Wakesetter 247
      2007 Yamaha AR210

      Comment

      • TxJole
        Senior Member of PLANETNAUTIQUE
        • Jun 2009
        • 898

        • Cedar Creek Lake TEXAS


        #4
        I like my 1579 over my 1235 because if its not butter it will grind air. Right now I have my 645 on because we r driving around ( 2 newborns ) more then pulling.
        2008 210 SAN TE (Moonraker Yellow over Midnight Blue)

        Comment

        • moto822
          • Jul 2012
          • 104

          • Green Bay, WI

          • SAN 230 TE Sold - 08 Calabria Pro v2

          #5
          Hey,

          On my 2010 230 I had the 1235 but it would not plane out with the amount of water I was running. I went with the 2079 and it has been awesome. I lost about 2 MPH on the top and gained a ton of hole shot. I run 1100's in the back and another 650 in the bow. Without it I was not leveling out.

          Moto
          Current - SAN 230 TE
          Sold - 08 Calabria Pro v2

          Comment

          • 08sante
            • Apr 2013
            • 38

            • Utah

            • Current- 2008 Super Air Nautique 230 TE

            #6
            Originally posted by moto822 View Post
            Hey,

            On my 2010 230 I had the 1235 but it would not plane out with the amount of water I was running. I went with the 2079 and it has been awesome. I lost about 2 MPH on the top and gained a ton of hole shot. I run 1100's in the back and another 650 in the bow. Without it I was not leveling out.

            Moto
            I made the same swap in my 08 230.. Best move I have ever made.. what motor do you have in yours Moto?

            Comment

            • moto822
              • Jul 2012
              • 104

              • Green Bay, WI

              • SAN 230 TE Sold - 08 Calabria Pro v2

              #7
              343
              Current - SAN 230 TE
              Sold - 08 Calabria Pro v2

              Comment

              • Nordicron
                Senior Member of PLANETNAUTIQUE
                • Sep 2009
                • 557

                • Madison, WI


                #8
                I would take my 1235 over my 1579 any day of the week! My holeshot, top speed and rpm all got better with the 1235 over the 1579 on my 210. i have zero issue with cavitation also. Your 1235 must be outa spec or something.

                Comment

                • SlipNSlideKing
                  • Aug 2008
                  • 34

                  • Canada


                  #9
                  I absolutely have to buy a new prop for 2008 210 SANTE. Any reason I should go for the 1235? Do the reasons mentioned previously for the 230 apply to the 210? I assume not but I'd like make sure before I pull the plug.

                  If the 1235 is the way to go, anyone have a 1235 they want to sell me?

                  Comment

                  • Clibka
                    Senior Member of PLANETNAUTIQUE
                    • Dec 2012
                    • 406

                    • Illinois

                    • 2021 G23 2012 210 SANTE (Previous)

                    #10
                    1617. Go find Jeff's review.
                    First and Current - 2012 210 SANTE

                    Comment

                    • perry386
                      Senior Member of PLANETNAUTIQUE
                      • Jun 2012
                      • 560

                      • gadsden AL

                      • Super Air nautique 236

                      #11
                      Well, I guess I should have went 1235 in retrospect. Oh well, I don't run hardly any weight (only factory) so I think it will work out OK. I think my 1235 IS out of spec because it has been reworked so many times. There are little cavitation burns on the back of the propeller and nicks all over the front. On the plus side, the 1579 was a good bit cheaper.

                      Comment

                      • kaikane
                        • Sep 2008
                        • 47

                        • San Francisco, CA


                        #12
                        Triple the move to the 2079 on my 08 230. You lose some top end but really makes a difference for our targeted uses which are wakeboarding and surfing with ballast. Have the 343 and really wakes up the engine on the bottom end. Also think it helps with 5 mph maneuverability in tight places. 1235 was reconditioned and sitting in the bilge as backup.

                        Comment

                        • shirlz72
                          • Jan 2013
                          • 19

                          • nsw, australia

                          • 2010 SAN 230

                          #13
                          Originally posted by 08sante View Post
                          I made the same swap in my 08 230.. Best move I have ever made.. what motor do you have in yours Moto?
                          Hi what motor do you have in yours? I have the zr409 in mine. Same ballast setup though an extra 1400 in lead. I have the 1235 though am looking for more holeshot as it wont get out with too many people in the boat. Would the 2079 be suitable for the 6l also? It doesn't make the wake washy or anything does it?

                          Comment

                          Working...
                          X