Removable pylon broke on my '13 200v

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • NautiqueOasis
    • Oct 2005
    • 142

    • Dayton, OH

    • '13 200V Sport; '05 SV211; '97, '90 , '85 & '79 Sk

    #1

    Removable pylon broke on my '13 200v

    Pulling a 180 lb skier through the course last week and heard a loud pop as skier rounded ball and pulling to the wake. Glanced at the pylon and it had a significant lean towards back of the boat. Broken pylon sleeve in attached pic shows where the weld busted loose; the actual pylon still securely in sleeve. The sleeve was only welded between the two inserts that connected into the aluminum face. Contacted dealer for warranty replacement; Nautique sent next day air to my dock so very little downtime. I received great service from both dealer and Nautique; however, I was extremely disappointed that the weld could break on the pylon sleeve. The replacement sleeve was welded across the entire face surface; wonder if they have had this issue before and now reinforce their pylon sleeves.
    Attached Files
    '13 200V Sport Nautique
    '05 SV211 Nautique
    '97 Ski Nautique
    '90 Ski Nautique
    '85 Ski Nautique
    '79 Ski Nautique
  • sodbuster88
    Senior Member of PLANETNAUTIQUE
    • Nov 2008
    • 368

    • Clayton, NC


    #2
    Man....I knew that would happen... Mine came from the factory with the pylon leaning significantly to SB. Had to do with mis-aligned holes in the structure. Decided to fix it myself and when I was in there, I noticed the same thing (sub-standard weld at that joint) so I machined an extra bolt hole through the pylon / sleeve so we could use the boom. Haven't had a problem...yet.
    Peace..

    Comment

    • NautiqueOasis
      • Oct 2005
      • 142

      • Dayton, OH

      • '13 200V Sport; '05 SV211; '97, '90 , '85 & '79 Sk

      #3
      Did you use a U-bolt around pylon and then thru sleeve to reinforce?
      '13 200V Sport Nautique
      '05 SV211 Nautique
      '97 Ski Nautique
      '90 Ski Nautique
      '85 Ski Nautique
      '79 Ski Nautique

      Comment

      • sodbuster88
        Senior Member of PLANETNAUTIQUE
        • Nov 2008
        • 368

        • Clayton, NC


        #4
        My intention was actually not so much in beefing up that joint...rather, to make the pylon more robust in the receptacle because I didn't trust the nylon foot / lock pin for forces that can be applied rotationally and vertically (for a boom). So I just added a pin hole to go through the sleeve and the receptacle that locks the pylon in place using a 5/8 x 4 SS pull pin. In my case, I didn't fix the weld, but adds another fastener to hold pylon to sleeve...so still susceptible to the same failure as you experienced.
        Peace..

        Comment

        • seth
          Senior Member of PLANETNAUTIQUE
          • Jun 2008
          • 549

          • Santa Barbara, CA

          • 01 SAN-sold

          #5
          That whole setup looks poorly designed. Did the engineers think they were making a mount for a table???

          Comment

          • NautiqueOasis
            • Oct 2005
            • 142

            • Dayton, OH

            • '13 200V Sport; '05 SV211; '97, '90 , '85 & '79 Sk

            #6
            Click image for larger version

Name:	image (1).jpg
Views:	1
Size:	15.6 KB
ID:	368840

            Here is an additional pic of the sleeve attached to the mounting bracket/brace in the floor
            '13 200V Sport Nautique
            '05 SV211 Nautique
            '97 Ski Nautique
            '90 Ski Nautique
            '85 Ski Nautique
            '79 Ski Nautique

            Comment

            • sodbuster88
              Senior Member of PLANETNAUTIQUE
              • Nov 2008
              • 368

              • Clayton, NC


              #7
              Here is link to thread with my pylon work...

              http://www.planetnautique.com/vb3/sh...373#post191373
              Peace..

              Comment

              Working...
              X