If Chad's rig is "vintage" than mine must be ancient history! 1993 Ford Lightning - 2003 SANTE
X
-
Originally posted by Kmayotte View Post
Way below a normal F-150. A quick look through the online specs, the 2017 (non-raptors) with the Eco-Boost are rated for over 11K towing.
Comment
-
-
Senior Member of PLANETNAUTIQUE
- Oct 2014
- 563
- Radford VA
- 2016 Nautique G23. Masters Blue/Gunmetal Flake
Originally posted by SANonSherman View Post
Not sure I agree that there is an easy lawsuit. Changing only the axle ratio or going to a smaller engine can dramatically reduce the rated towing capacity. Same brakes, same suspension, same truck except one will accelerate slower and will have a harder time maintaining its speed going uphill.
I believe to win the lawsuit it would be necessary to prove that being overweight is the cause of the accident, simply being over the manufacturer's rated limit isn't automatic cause.
That being said, if I towed my boat frequently or for long trips I would definitely want the best possible setup, including engine, axle ratio, etc. If towing only involves going from storage to the lake in the spring then a return trip in the fall, engines and axles wouldn't be a major concern.
Side Note: I like the Raptor but prefer the Ram Rebel, the Rebel (Crew Cab, Hemi, 4x4, 3.92 axle) is rated for 9,950 lbs.
Comment
-
Senior Member of PLANETNAUTIQUE
- Oct 2014
- 563
- Radford VA
- 2016 Nautique G23. Masters Blue/Gunmetal Flake
The whole reason the Raptor has such a low towing capacity is because of the suspension. It's an off road suspension meaning when a lot of weight is added to the rear, such as with a boat trailer, the rear end of the truck is pushed down, which alleviates weight over the front axels, which in turn reduces traction on the front tires thus reducing steering and braking properties. This is the reason why 250/2500 trucks have a higher towing capacity even when they might have the same motor as the 150/1500 series trucks. This is also the reason they ride a lot stiffer...because of the stiffer rear leaf springs. One thing you can do to help with this is to get a set of air bags added to the rear to help level the ride back out when the trailer weight is added...however, that kinda takes a little away from the reason of buying an off road truck like the Raptor in the first place. Unless you're only really buying the truck for looks and not off roading, in which case the air bags would work well.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Beg4wake View Post
Thats is a big fat negative sir! I personally know somebody spending 5-10 years for manslaughter for this EXACT reason. He was towing over weight, couldn't stop in an emergency braking situation and rear ended a car, going over the top of it completely demolishing the cab and killed the driver. The judge wasted no time at all slamming the hammer on him simply because he was overweight. Oh and btw...he only towed the boat 5-7 miles to get to the lake.
Based on your comments, you seem to be in full agreement with that statement, so let's setup a scenario.
I went to the Ford website (https://www.ford.com/resources/ford/..._F150_Sep7.pdf) and found that a F150 Supercab 4x4 with 5L engine can tow:
- 9,000 lbs with 3.31 gear ratio
- 10,900 lbs with 3.73 gear ratio
Let's assume you and I had one of these trucks (this would never happen since I prefer Ram trucks....), they're identical in every way except you have 3.73 gears and I have 3.31 gears and we're each towing a 10,000 lb trailer with the proper weight distribution hitch, trailer brakes, etc. The only difference is the gear ratio.
Three scenarios:
1) We're stopped at a red light and we get rear ended
2) We're driving down the highway and someone changes lanes into our trailer
3) A car runs a red light as we enter an intersection and we hit it
Based on the comment that was made "easy lawsuit......whether it's your fault or not", in all 3 scenarios I'm an easy lawsuit but you would have no risk. I disagree. My lawyer may have to prove that my gear ratio had no impact to the accident and that my truck had appropriate brakes and suspension (remember, the same brakes and suspension as yours) for the load I was towing.
As a separate note, if you change your truck from the factory setup you may be affecting the manufacturers rated trailering limits. Example; if you install a lift kit on your truck in the example above, your 10,900 lb limit could decrease significantly. If you get into a bad accident and the injured person decides to sue, they would likely sue you and Ford. Ford would quickly show that their trailering ratings are correct but the truck had been modified. If it can be shown that your modifications reduced the trailering limits then you may be found to be liable, even though you're below the factory limits.
To be clear, if the tow vehicle has inadequate brakes, suspension, frame/body integrity, etc. then there is a clear safety issue and it should not tow the trailer under any circumstances.
I certainly don't know the details of the fatal accident that you mentioned but if the brakes, suspension, etc. weren't rated for the load that was being towed then I agree, that's completely unsafe and indefensible.Last edited by SANonTellico; 01-29-2017, 12:42 AM.Previously: 2015 SAN 210
Comment
-
-
I drove a 2017 Super Duty diesel the other day and it was a BEAST. The new PS is awesome. I would have definitely went SD but not my coin to spend.
I'm interested to see pics of the raptor towing a G.
Bevostein on page 1. You need to teach your son not to wear his shoes on the boat...jussayin
Comment
-
-
Senior Member of PLANETNAUTIQUE
- Oct 2014
- 563
- Radford VA
- 2016 Nautique G23. Masters Blue/Gunmetal Flake
Originally posted by SANonSherman View Post
Beg4wake: This is what was someone posted and what I was replying to: "8k on paper makes for a real easy lawsuit if you ever get in a wreck while you're over loaded, which you are... whether it's your fault or not."
Based on your comments, you seem to be in full agreement with that statement, so let's setup a scenario.
I went to the Ford website (https://www.ford.com/resources/ford/..._F150_Sep7.pdf) and found that a F150 Supercab 4x4 with 5L engine can tow:
- 9,000 lbs with 3.31 gear ratio
- 10,900 lbs with 3.73 gear ratio
Let's assume you and I had one of these trucks (this would never happen since I prefer Ram trucks....), they're identical in every way except you have 3.73 gears and I have 3.31 gears and we're each towing a 10,000 lb trailer with the proper weight distribution hitch, trailer brakes, etc. The only difference is the gear ratio.
Three scenarios:
1) We're stopped at a red light and we get rear ended
2) We're driving down the highway and someone changes lanes into our trailer
3) A car runs a red light as we enter an intersection and we hit it
Based on the comment that was made "easy lawsuit......whether it's your fault or not", in all 3 scenarios I'm an easy lawsuit but you would have no risk. I disagree. My lawyer may have to prove that my gear ratio had no impact to the accident and that my truck had appropriate brakes and suspension (remember, the same brakes and suspension as yours) for the load I was towing.
As a separate note, if you change your truck from the factory setup you may be affecting the manufacturers rated trailering limits. Example; if you install a lift kit on your truck in the example above, your 10,900 lb limit could decrease significantly. If you get into a bad accident and the injured person decides to sue, they would likely sue you and Ford. Ford would quickly show that their trailering ratings are correct but the truck had been modified. If it can be shown that your modifications reduced the trailering limits then you may be found to be liable, even though you're below the factory limits.
To be clear, if the tow vehicle has inadequate brakes, suspension, frame/body integrity, etc. then there is a clear safety issue and it should not tow the trailer under any circumstances.
I certainly don't know the details of the fatal accident that you mentioned but if the brakes, suspension, etc. weren't rated for the load that was being towed then I agree, that's completely unsafe and indefensible.
Comment
-
1,000 Post Club Member
- Oct 2014
- 1026
- St. George, Utah
- Red Metal Flake 2016 G23! Malibu 25 LSV 2019 2021 Centurion Ri237
Originally posted by Quinner View PostBeg, that is a tough deal about your friend and of course the victim. What exactly was the issue(s) that made it criminal??
Comment
-
1,000 Post Club Member
- Jan 2004
- 1070
- Texas
- 2021 G23 Previous 2015 G21 2010 226 2005 226 2000 Super Air
Originally posted by DocPhil View PostI drove a 2017 Super Duty diesel the other day and it was a BEAST. The new PS is awesome. I would have definitely went SD but not my coin to spend.
I'm interested to see pics of the raptor towing a G.
Bevostein on page 1. You need to teach your son not to wear his shoes on the boat...jussayin
Comment
-
Senior Member of PLANETNAUTIQUE
- Oct 2014
- 563
- Radford VA
- 2016 Nautique G23. Masters Blue/Gunmetal Flake
Originally posted by Quinner View PostBeg, that is a tough deal about your friend and of course the victim. What exactly was the issue(s) that made it criminal??
Comment
-
Senior Member of PLANETNAUTIQUE
- Oct 2014
- 563
- Radford VA
- 2016 Nautique G23. Masters Blue/Gunmetal Flake
Yup! I did, however I don't know how accurate the scale really read. It was a scale used by my company to determine the weight of a load in a truck before and after a trailer is emptied. It honestly may be off by hundred pounds or two.
Comment
Comment