G23 450 stalling

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Laketexoma
    Senior Member of PLANETNAUTIQUE
    • Dec 2004
    • 463

    • Lake Texoma (Texas side)

    • 2023 G23

    G23 450 stalling

    Anyone else had a problem with the 450hp stalling when going form in gear to neutral? Mine has done it quite a few times. It starts right back up, was told PCM is working on a fix. Just wondering if anyone else is having a problem?
    2016 G23 H6
    2014 G23 550
    2013 G23 450 (Great boat)
    2008 230 Team-ZR6- ACME 1235 ( back in a Nautique again)
    2005 Malibu LSV 23 wakesetter (Real Dumb Mistake)
    2000 SAN ( Loved that boat)
    1998 Air Nautique ( our first boat)
  • robertsmcfarland
    Senior Member of PLANETNAUTIQUE
    • Oct 2004
    • 544

    • Hyco

    • 2014 g23 550

    #2
    sorry not here
    2013 G23 super air
    2010 230 super air
    2009 220 super air
    2008 210 super air
    2005 210 super air
    2003 calabria pro air

    Comment

    • nyryan2001
      1,000 Post Club Member
      • Mar 2013
      • 1993

      • Lake Anna


      #3
      yep, 30hrs, its done it twice and came close a few more times.... slightly low idle IMO.... especially when you have a lot of electronics running, 3x pumps, fan, stereo etc etc.
      2019 G23 450
      2014 G23 550
      2013 G23 450
      2011 Malibu Wakesetter 247
      2007 Yamaha AR210

      Comment

      • bsb4fsu
        • Nov 2010
        • 333

        • East Tennessee

        • 2021 G23

        #4
        Mine has stalled once in the 40 hours I have on the boat. My dealer has said he has seen the issue on severe G's.
        2021 G23 450 - Current
        2019 G23 450 - Sold
        2018 G23 450 - Sold
        2017 G23 450 - Sold
        2016 G23 450 - Sold
        2014 G23 550 - Sold
        2013 G23 450 - Sold
        2012 210 - Sold
        2012 200 Mapple - Sold
        2011 230 - Sold

        Comment

        • Laketexoma
          Senior Member of PLANETNAUTIQUE
          • Dec 2004
          • 463

          • Lake Texoma (Texas side)

          • 2023 G23

          #5
          Glad I'm not the only one!! LOL mine was pulling the kids, no pumps or anything running. Just taking out slack in the rope. it did it multiple times in one day. I only have 3hrs on the boat.
          2016 G23 H6
          2014 G23 550
          2013 G23 450 (Great boat)
          2008 230 Team-ZR6- ACME 1235 ( back in a Nautique again)
          2005 Malibu LSV 23 wakesetter (Real Dumb Mistake)
          2000 SAN ( Loved that boat)
          1998 Air Nautique ( our first boat)

          Comment

          • JamesHawk101
            • Dec 2012
            • 224

            • Indian Rocks Beach

            • 2015 G23 Coastal

            #6
            Mine didn't it once the other day. I was just idleing towards a rider and lost power.
            2015 G23 Coastal Edition 450 NSS
            2013 G23 Coastal Edition 450 NSS

            Comment

            • ers906
              Senior Member of PLANETNAUTIQUE
              • Feb 2010
              • 921

              • Phoenix AZ

              • 2013 G23 550 hp (ordered and awaiting delivery) 2002 Super Sport (coverted into a SAN) 330 hp Excaliber 1994 Sun Tracker Party Barge 115 hp 1989 Horizon 200 Four Winns - sold 1989 Regal Commodore 280 - previous Possibly looking into picking up a 70'2-80's Nautique to rebuild as a ski boat

              #7
              Has anyone had this problem with a 550?
              Eric, Phoenix AZ

              G23 550 hp (finally here)
              2002 Super Air
              1994 Sun Tracker Party Barge 115 hp

              Comment

              • robertsmcfarland
                Senior Member of PLANETNAUTIQUE
                • Oct 2004
                • 544

                • Hyco

                • 2014 g23 550

                #8
                what are the dealers saying, about the problems and possible fixes
                2013 G23 super air
                2010 230 super air
                2009 220 super air
                2008 210 super air
                2005 210 super air
                2003 calabria pro air

                Comment

                • Laketexoma
                  Senior Member of PLANETNAUTIQUE
                  • Dec 2004
                  • 463

                  • Lake Texoma (Texas side)

                  • 2023 G23

                  #9
                  I was told that PCM knows about it and is making a flash for he pcm. Not sure when, but it is a known problem.
                  2016 G23 H6
                  2014 G23 550
                  2013 G23 450 (Great boat)
                  2008 230 Team-ZR6- ACME 1235 ( back in a Nautique again)
                  2005 Malibu LSV 23 wakesetter (Real Dumb Mistake)
                  2000 SAN ( Loved that boat)
                  1998 Air Nautique ( our first boat)

                  Comment

                  • philb
                    • Jan 2009
                    • 125

                    • Australia


                    #10
                    Originally posted by Laketexoma View Post
                    I was told that PCM knows about it and is making a flash for he pcm. Not sure when, but it is a known problem.
                    PCM have had the reflash out for about a month. I waited for the NSS to arrive (this week) & had the reflash done at the same time.

                    Comment

                    • robertsmcfarland
                      Senior Member of PLANETNAUTIQUE
                      • Oct 2004
                      • 544

                      • Hyco

                      • 2014 g23 550

                      #11
                      it all ways amazes me how different dealers receive technical information on fixes, some are instance , some say they have not heard of a problem, case in point Laketexoma dealer saying a flash is being made, philp dealer had the flash for over a month, that's why its all ways good to question a response and to ask for a second opinion .
                      2013 G23 super air
                      2010 230 super air
                      2009 220 super air
                      2008 210 super air
                      2005 210 super air
                      2003 calabria pro air

                      Comment

                      • rod 007
                        • Apr 2013
                        • 10

                        • lake norman

                        • G25 G25 230 236 226 210

                        #12
                        my G25 450 stalls all the time flash did not fix

                        Comment

                        • sja
                          • Jun 2012
                          • 66

                          • minneapolis

                          • 2013 Nautique G23 XS550

                          #13
                          Originally posted by ers906 View Post
                          Has anyone had this problem with a 550?
                          Haven't had this problem with my 550, but I have been surprised at the rough sounding (low RPM) idle. This is different from other boats I have had in past.

                          Comment

                          • rod 007
                            • Apr 2013
                            • 10

                            • lake norman

                            • G25 G25 230 236 226 210

                            #14
                            2 computer updates and still stalls

                            Comment

                            • vision
                              Senior Member of PLANETNAUTIQUE
                              • Jul 2011
                              • 515

                              • NC

                              • 2013 G23

                              #15
                              My has stalled 3 times in 135 hours. Always when dropping back to idle. Simply idles down to about 500rpm and stalls. So infrequent I have not even mentioned it to my dealer.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X